Skip Navigation

Country list enhancement

Travel Forums System Talk Country list enhancement

1. Posted by nzhamsta (Respected Member 93 posts) 3y

Hi,
Might I suggest an enhancement to the country list in the optional details. I am writing an entry that covers a whole region (the Middle East) and I wish to tag it as such.

Therefore my suggestion is that the country list also includes regions, for example:
Europe
Middle East
Africa (maybe split into North, West, etc)
Central Asia
South East Asia
Pacific Ocean

and so on.

This will allow entries to be properly tagged.

This sort of regional tagging would also be good on the photo location tags. I have photos that do not really apply to one country but are best tagged as "Middle East".

Regards,

Glynn

2. Posted by Peter (Admin 5532 posts) 3y

You could tag the blog entry (or photo) with region names if you like. That would seem to achieve what you're looking for wouldn't it?

3. Posted by nzhamsta (Respected Member 93 posts) 3y

Hi,
Sorry for delay in replying, just arrived in Italy. The tags would work but I think it would still be an improvement to have the regions as well in the "country" field. You can publish a page with nothing in the "country" field and it does not appear on the list of countries on the right hand side.
I might also have mixed up "tags" with "location / country" in my original post, just to add to the confusion.
Photos require a mandatory location which in some cases might not be appropriate.

Cheers,
Glynn

4. Posted by Peter (Admin 5532 posts) 3y

There's a couple of problems I can see adding predefined regions to the main country list.

1. We would need a good list of regions. This is not as easy as a list of countries (which is already a nightmare to maintain!)
2. The dropdown list where you select the country would become VERY long. There are a lot more regions around the world, then there are countries.
3. It's hard to draw the line with regions. Some people will want states in there (only natural). Some will want regions within states.

What I'd be more inclined to do is provide an option to tag the post as *several* separate countries. So you wouldn't need to just select one. That would seem to cover part of the issue for you which is that just selecting one country does not reflect the post content that well.

5. Posted by nzhamsta (Respected Member 93 posts) 3y

And now for something right out of left field.

I am currently posting all my historical travels and am travelling back through the mists of time to 1986, i.e. back before the fall of the Wall.
What are the chances of having the following countries added to the country list:

Czechoslovakia
Soviet Union
Yugoslavia

These would be more accurate than the current day entities of Russia etc.

Many thanks,
Glynn

6. Posted by Peter (Admin 5532 posts) 3y

Well, that is an interesting suggestion :) Our trend has always been to keeping it reflecting current countries. There could be a lot of problems trying to support old names of places as well as the current ones. I'm not really sure I want to head down this route for that reason really.

My inclination is to say that this is probably too rare a feature to build into our main country list. It might just confuse a lot of people into entering the wrong thing.

7. Posted by nzhamsta (Respected Member 93 posts) 3y

I understand your thinking.

However, one possible way to avoid any confusion is to have a "Historical section" at the bottom of the main list, i.e. after the end of the current alphabetical list and headed up as such.